Cancer patients in KZN must ‘relocate to another province or die’ as last specialist in Durban resigns

Cancer patients in KZN must ‘relocate to another province or die’ as last specialist in Durban resigns

By Bongani Mthethwa, 8 June 2017,

As of the close of business on Friday‚ there will not be a single cancer specialist doctor employed at any state hospital in Durban – and only two will be left in KwaZulu-Natal.

This shocking development leaves hundreds – if not thousands – of cancer patients in KwaZulu-Natal’s biggest city facing clinical uncertainty and staring the possibility of death squarely in the face. It follows the resignation of the city’s last state oncologist‚ whose last day is Friday.

Dr Thilomi Naidoo was the only cancer doctor remaining at the Inkosi Albert Luthuli Central Hospital following the resignation of another oncologist‚ Dr Sanele Kunene‚ earlier this month. Her departure means that the 846-bed referral hospital‚ one of the most sophisticated in the world and which treats about 80% of the provinces’s cancer patients‚ will be left with no oncologist.

Oncology services‚ including radiotherapy‚ are provided at just three hospitals in KwaZulu-Natal: Inkosi Albert Luthuli and Addington in Durban‚ and Grey’s Hospital in Pietermaritzburg. Only two oncologists are left at Grey’s following a massive exodus from state hospitals to the more lucrative private sector – and this not just to chase more money‚ but also because of difficult working conditions.

Attempts to get a comment from the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Health on Thursday were unsuccessful. Department spokesman Desmond Motha did not respond to either email or text messages‚ and Health MEC Sibongiseni Dhlomo said he was in meetings and would respond at his convenience.

Dr Mvuyisi Mzukwa‚ spokesman and chairman of the SA Medical Association’s KZN coastal branch‚ confirmed the situation.

“Yes‚ it’s correct‚ the last remaining oncologist [in Durban] is leaving tomorrow [Friday] which means we only have two remaining oncologists in the province‚ which is at Grey’s Hospital‚” he said. Mzukwa said this left patients in a dire position.

“It’s a big blow to poor patients that cannot afford private care. It’s an indictment because it leaves them with two options – to relocate to another province or to die. The provincial government is not their hope at the moment‚” he said.

At least two cancer patients’ families have attributed their untimely deaths to the non-functional cancer treatment equipment at Addington‚ according to a statement released ahead of a march by doctors in Durban.

Both patients were reportedly referred to Inkosi Albert Luthuli hospital as oncology machines at Addington were allegedly broken. But because of excessively long waiting lists‚ they died before they could be treated.

Democratic Alliance MPL Dr Imran Keeka said the party had submitted a complaint to the SA Human Rights Commission in February last year about the collapse of the oncology service. He said a report‚ which has not been made public yet‚ was forwarded to him and the respondents‚ KwaZulu-Natal Health MEC Dr Sibongiseni Dhlomo‚ the KZN Department of Health‚ and officials at Addington and Inkosi Albert Luthuli.

“Because the report cannot be made public as yet‚ the contents cannot be divulged. The DA is hopeful that the unchanged report is made public very soon‚” he said.

Keeka alleged that Addington’s radiotherapy devices procured in 2009 have never been properly maintained and “they have now become totally dysfunctional”.

“Oncologists have provided solid reasons for leaving. Those that I have spoken to give reasons ranging from not being able to continue working in an environment that is overburdened by the sheer number of patients‚ the patronage systems in the department‚ seeing immense suffering because of the failing healthcare structures and broken equipment‚” he said.

Keeka‚ who is also a member of the provincial health portfolio committee‚ said the waiting time for some patients to see an oncologist could range anywhere from between three to nine months.

“The impact of the exodus of the oncologists has nothing to do with greener pastures. An oncologist that recently resigned said to me that she would love to continue working for the department but simply cannot under the circumstances‚” said Keeka.

In February‚ the DA wrote to KwaZulu-Natal Premier Willies Mchunu calling for him to axe Dhlomo because of the deterioration of the healthcare services in the province.

A written reply to questions asked by Keeka showed that the most commonly seen cancer patients at Inkosi Albert Luthuli between 2015/16 and 2016/17 were those with cervix cancer (946) and breast cancer (772).

Dhlomo was quoted in local media earlier this month as saying that there were no oncologists left in public health to train new oncology doctors. He said the University of KwaZulu-Natal’s Nelson R Mandela School of Medicine would also lose its Health Professions Council of SA accreditation to train in oncology as a result of the mass resignations.

In March‚ the Health and Other Services Personnel Trade Union of South Africa (Hospersa) slammed the provincial department for failure to resolve the ongoing cancer treatment crisis in the province.

The union called on Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi to urgently address the crisis.

“It seems that this problem is just dragging on without government stepping in fixing the problem. Meanwhile‚ people are suffering and even dying‚” said Hospersa general secretary Noel Desfontaines

KZN Health MEC Sibongiseni Dhlomo said on Thursday evening that the resignation of the last oncologist at Inkosi Albert Luthili was regrettable as it was taking the province backwards in terms of the service that they had prepared at the hospital. However‚ he denied that doctors were leaving the hospital because they were frustrated by working conditions.

“People are leaving Inkosi Albert Luthuli because of their own desires to make more money‚ but not because it has given them frustration in terms of equipment. I would agree if you say we need to improve this-and-that at a particular hospital. But people are leaving for other reasons and those are people who want to go and to go and treat rich patients‚” said Dhlomo.

He said the department would rely on oncologists at Grey’s Hospital to treat cancer patients at Inkosi Albert Luthuli. A private group of onconlogists called Rainbow Oncologists have also committed to giving support.

The department will also speak to those doctors who have left to ascertain whether they are willing to offer it their services but “we would rather ask them to come to our own hospitals where we have equipment to treat our patients there and pay for their professional services because it will be costly to send patients to them and pay for their equipment”.

Dhlomo said they also need to continue to train other specialists but that those should be people who are patriotic about their country.

HASA Pulse 2022

Read the latest HASA Pulse by clicking here

Search Centre

News Archives

Fill in your details to

Sign Up for Our Monthly Newsletter

We don’t spam. Our newsletter is filled with research articles and HASA related content and announcements.